Battleangel

Gamespy actually manages to put together a well-rounded list of games and sorting out the bad apples as well.

Gamespy - PC Top 10 Games of the Year
1. Civilization IV
2. Battlefield 2
3. Call of Duty 2
4. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
5. Age of Empires III
6. Guild Wars
7. F.E.A.R.
8. Freedom Force vs. the 3rd Reich
9. SWAT 4
10. Silent Hunter III
HM. World of Warcraft

They seem awfully thrilled with Guild Wars. Take that WoW.